Development and experimental validation of a dynamic numerical model for human articular cartilage

Abstract

The purpose of this study was to create a preliminary set of experimentally validated Finite Element Analysis (FEA) models, in order to predict the dynamic mechanical behaviour of human articular cartilage (AC). Current models consider static loading with limited independent experimental validation, while the models for this study assess dynamic loading of AC, with direct comparison and validation to physical testing. Three different FEA models of AC were constructed, which considered both linear elastic and hyperelastic models; Neo-Hookean and Ogden. Models were validated using the data collected from compression testing of human femoral heads across 0–1.7 MPa (quasi-static tests and dynamic mechanical analysis). The linear elastic model was inadequate, with a 10-fold over prediction of the displacement dynamic amplitude. The Neo-Hookean model accurately predicted the dynamic amplitude but failed to predict the initial compression of the cartilage, with a 10 times overprediction. The Ogden model provided the best results, with both the initial compression lying within one standard deviation of that observed in the validation data set, and the dynamic amplitude of the same order of magnitude. In conclusion, this study has found that the fast dynamic response of human AC is best represented by a third order Ogden model.