Comparative research on the pipe-soil frictional resistances of circular and rectangular pipe sections during trenchless pipe jacking

Abstract

Pipe jacking is a trenchless construction method to achieve forward tunneling and efficient construction of underground structure simultaneously without extensive surface excavation. In the process of pipe jacking construction, the jacking force provided by the hydraulic jacking equipment must overcome the frontal resistance of the cutter head and the frictional resistance between the pipe sections and formation at the same time. In particular, the pipe-soil frictional resistance increases with the increases of jacking distance, buried depth, pipe diameter and the complexity of jacking trajectory. Therefore, it is very important to correctly estimate jacking force in trenchless jacking engineering practice for the smooth implementation of pipe jacking, operation risk and comprehensive cost control. Firstly, the stress states of jacking circular and rectangular pipe sections in the soil are analyzed, and the key influencing factors of their pipe-soil frictional resistance are obtained respectively. Then, the pipe-soil frictional resistance of jacking the circular and rectangular pipe sections with the same external surface area in the dry sandy soil and coal granular layer are tested separately by using the self-developed multifunctional experimental apparatus during trenchless pipe jacking. The results show that the pipe-soil frictional resistances of jacking circular and rectangular pipe sections in the coal granular layer are always smaller than that in the sandy soil under the same experimental conditions, and the corresponding fitting calculation equation of pipe-soil frictional resistances are obtained respectively. Meanwhile, the modified calculation methods of the above pipe-soil frictional resistances are proposed respectively based on the relationship between the lateral pressure coefficient K and the buried depth of pipe section H. Moreover, the disturbed area of soil in the upper part of jacking circular pipe section presents an arc distribution, while the disturbed area of soil in the upper part of jacking rectangular pipe section presents a slightly concave distribution. Due to the different disturbance conditions of soil around the pipe section, the lateral pressure coefficient K should be corrected in the calculation equations of pipe-soil frictional resistance of jacking circular and rectangular pipe sections based on the discrete element numerical simulation analysis by EDEM software. Finally, the pipe-soil frictional resistances obtained by different methods in the sandy soil are compared and analyzed. The calculated values of the modified theoretical calculation method are very close to the experimental test values, while the other methods are smaller than the experimental test values, which makes the rationality of the modified theoretical calculation method of pipe-soil frictional resistance is verified, and some suggestions are also put forward for the value of some coefficients in the relevant empirical estimation equations. The above research achievements systematically compared the states of pipe-soil frictional resistances of jacking circular and rectangular pipe sections based on different research methods, especially for the correct evaluation of jacking force during trenchless pipe jacking, they could provide some valuable references and effective guidance for the subsequent research, engineering practice and further development of trenchless pipe jacking technology.