Assembly FMEA: A Simplified Method for Identifying Assembly Errors

Abstract

Manual assembly errors are a significant source of manufacturing defects. Therefore, an efficient method is needed to identify and alleviate potential assembly defects. Process Failure Modes and Effects Analysis (Process FMEA) is one technique used to anticipate, evaluate, and resolve potential manufacturing and assembly issues. However, performing FMEA is widely considered to be tedious and time-consuming, and not always worth the effort. In response, many researchers have attempted to automate FMEA using Artificial Intelligence (AI) to make it less arduous. Unfortunately, automated techniques are limited to systems with predictable behaviors (e.g., electronic circuits) and are rarely used on unpredictable processes such as manual assembly. “Assembly FMEA” is a novel technique developed specifically to identify manual assembly errors. Assembly defect levels are related to assembly complexity, which can be estimated using “Design for Assembly” (DFA) time penalties. Hence, Assembly FMEA uses a series of DFA-related questions to elicit potential assembly defects. The questions help to focus, standardize, and expedite the FMEA process. Assembly FMEA quickly identifies a large number of assembly errors with significantly less effort than conventional FMEA. This paper describes the Assembly FMEA procedure and illustrates its use on a conceptual design and on an existing product.