Longitudinal Speech Outcome at 5 and 10 Years in UCLP: Influence of Speech Therapy and Secondary Velopharyngeal Surgery

Abstract

Objective To investigate speech development of children aged 5 and 10 years with repaired unilateral cleft lip and palate (UCLP) and identify speech characteristics when speech proficiency is not at ‘peer level’ at 10 years. Estimate how the number of speech therapy visits are related to speech proficiency at 10 years, and what factors are predictive of whether a child's speech proficiency at 10 years is at ‘peer level’ or not. Design Longitudinal complete datasets from the Scandcleft project Participants 320 children from nine cleft palate teams in five countries, operated on with one out of four surgical methods. Interventions Secondary velopharyngeal surgery (VP-surgery) and number of speech therapy visits (ST-visits), a proxy for speech intervention. Main Outcome Measures ‘Peer level’ of percentage of consonants correct (PCC, > 91%) and the composite score of velopharyngeal competence (VPC-Sum, 0–1). Results Speech proficiency improved, with only 23% of the participants at ‘peer level’ at 5 years, compared to 56% at 10 years. A poorer PCC score was the most sensitive marker for the 44% below ‘peer level’ at 10-year-of-age. The best predictor of ‘peer level’ speech proficiency at 10 years was speech proficiency at 5 years. A high number of ST-visits received did not improve the probability of achieving ‘peer level’ speech, and many children seemed to have received excessive amounts of ST-visits without substantial improvement. Conclusions It is important to strive for speech at ‘peer level’ before age 5. Criteria for speech therapy intervention and for methods used needs to be evidence-based.