STATUS CONSISTENCY AND WORK SATISFACTION AMONG PROFESSIONAL AND MANAGERIAL WOMEN AND MEN

Abstract

This study examined whether holding a status-consistent or status-inconsistent position (based on the gender of respondents and the percentage of women and men in their occupation nationally) affected the work satisfaction of college-educated, white-collar employees. The status-consistent group contained 128 women and 118 men. The status-inconsistent group was composed of 89 women and 102 men. Our results indicated that workers in occupations in which the majority of workers are the same gender had significantly higher levels of work satisfaction than those in status-inconsistent occupations. However, subsequent analyses revealed that men and women employed in occupations in which the majority of workers are men had higher levels of work satisfaction than those employed in women-dominated occupations. These findings held when controlling for other work-satisfaction factors, such as individual earnings, hours worked per week, and length of time employed. We suggest that the effect of status consistency on work satisfaction is mediated by the cultural value attached to the occupations men dominate.