Performance and Return to Sport After Latissimus Dorsi and Teres Major Tears Among Professional Baseball Pitchers

Abstract

Background: Latissimus dorsi and teres major (LD/TM) tears are becoming an increasingly common cause of injury and disability among professional baseball pitchers. Purpose/Hypothesis: To determine performance and return to sport (RTS) among professional baseball pitchers after LD/TM tears treated operatively and nonoperatively and to compare the RTS rate and performance between pitchers who sustained an LD/TM tear and matched controls. The authors hypothesized a high RTS rate among professional baseball pitchers after LD/TM tears, with no significant difference in RTS rate or performance between cases and controls for operative and nonoperative treatment—specifically, in the primary performance outcome variables of WHIP ([walks + hits] / innings pitched), fielding independent pitching, and wins above replacement. Study Design: Cohort study; Level of evidence, 3. Methods: All professional baseball pitchers who sustained an LD/TM tear between 2011 and 2016 were identified with the Health and Injury Tracking System database of Major League Baseball. Demographic and performance data (before and after injury) were recorded for each player. Performance metrics were then compared between cases and matched controls by operative and nonoperative treatment. Results: Overall, 120 pitchers had a documented LD/TM tear; 42 (35%) were major league players. Most players (n = 107, 89.2%) were treated nonoperatively. Time to return to the same level of competition was 170 ± 169 days (mean ± SD) for pitchers treated nonoperatively and 406 ± 146 days for those treated operatively. The RTS rate among players treated nonoperatively and operatively was identical at 75%. Players treated nonoperatively had no change in fielding independent pitching or wins above replacement after injury but had a higher (ie, worse) WHIP after injury ( P = .039); they also performed significantly worse in several secondary performance metrics, including number of games played per year ( P < .001). Players treated operatively had no change in any measured performance metrics after surgery. No difference existed between cases and controls in the primary performance variables. Conclusion: The majority of LD/TM tears are treated nonoperatively. The RTS rate is 75% for professional baseball pitchers after LD/TM tears treated operatively or nonoperatively. Players treated nonoperatively saw a decline in several performance metrics, while players treated operatively had no significant difference in performance after surgery.