Evaluation of Monkman–Grant strain as a key parameter in ductility exhaustion damage model to predict creep rupture of grade 92 steel

Abstract

Conventional strain-based numerical prediction assumes that failure occurs when ductility is exhausted or accumulation of creep strain reaches the critical failure strain. Due to instability at the onset of rupture, the failure strain value appears to be scattered and leads to the erroneousness in prediction. In this paper, a new local constraint-based damage model incorporating the Monkman–Grant ductility, as a measure of strain during uniform creep deformation stage, was implemented into a Finite Element (FE) model to predict the creep damage and rupture of Grade 92 steel under uniaxial and multiaxial stress states. The prediction was applied on plain and notched bar specimens with various notch acuities. The uniaxial stress-dependent Monkman–Grant (MG) failure strain was adopted in the FE to simulate the influence of the constraints which were induced by the creep damage. The implication of reduced failure strain in long-term creep time on the rupture prediction is discussed. The multiaxial MG failure strain of the notched bar, which has a lower value than uniaxial failure strain due to the geometrical constraint, was estimated based on the linear inverse relationship between normalised MG failure strain and normalised triaxiality factor. It was found that the results obtained from the proposed technique were in good agreement with the experimental data within the scatter band of ± factor of 2. It was shown that MG failure strain can be used as an alternative to strain at fracture. MG strain outweighed strain at fracture because the determination of its value only required short-term testing to be performed. In most cases considered in the present investigation, the rupture-type fracture was predicted, however, there was evidence that under high constraint and low stress, stable crack propagation occurred before fracture. The location of the maximum creep damage was found to be dependent on the creep time, geometry or acuity level of the specimen. For sharp notch specimen, the failure was initiated near the notch root, however, as the notch radius increased, the initiation location moved further away towards the specimen centre.