Trade-offs among transcription elongation rate, number, and duration of ubiquitous pauses on highly transcribed bacterial genes

Abstract

In this paper, we study the limitations imposed on the transcription process by the presence of short ubiquitous pauses and crowding. These effects are especially pronounced in highly transcribed genes such as ribosomal genes (rrn) in fast growing bacteria. Our model indicates that the quantity and duration of pauses reported for protein-coding genes is incompatible with the average elongation rate observed in rrn genes. When maximal elongation rate is high, pause-induced traffic jams occur, increasing promoter occlusion, thereby lowering the initiation rate. This lowers average transcription rate and increases average transcription time. Increasing maximal elongation rate in the model is insufficient to match the experimentally observed average elongation rate in rrn genes. This suggests that there may be rrn-specific modifications to RNAP, which then experience fewer pauses, or pauses of shorter duration than those in protein-coding genes. We identify model parameter triples (maximal elongation rate, mean pause duration time, number of pauses) which are compatible with experimentally observed elongation rates. Average transcription time and average transcription rate are the model outputs investigated as proxies for cell fitness. These fitness functions are optimized for different parameter choices, opening up a possibility of differential control of these aspects of the elongation process, with potential evolutionary consequences. As an example, a gene’s average transcription time may be crucial to fitness when the surrounding medium is prone to abrupt changes. This paper demonstrates that a functional relationship among the model parameters can be estimated using a standard statistical analysis, and this functional relationship describes the various trade-offs that must be made in order for the gene to control the elongation process and achieve a desired average transcription time. It also demonstrates the robustness of the system when a range of maximal elongation rates can be balanced with transcriptional pause data in order to maintain a desired fitness.