A learned score function improves the power of mass spectrometry database search

Abstract

AbstractOne of the core problems in the analysis of protein tandem mass spectrometry data is the peptide assignment problem: determining, for each observed spectrum, the peptide sequence that was responsible for generating the spectrum. Two primary classes of methods are used to solve this problem: database search andde novopeptide sequencing. State-of-the-art methods forde novosequencing employ machine learning methods, whereas most database search engines use hand-designed score functions to evaluate the quality of a match between an observed spectrum and a candidate peptide from the database. We hypothesize that machine learning models forde novosequencing implicitly learn a score function that captures the relationship between peptides and spectra, and thus may be re-purposed as a score function for database search. Because this score function is trained from massive amounts of mass spectrometry data, it could potentially outperform existing, hand-designed database search tools. To test this hypothesis, we re-engineered Casanovo, which has been shown to provide state-of-the-artde novosequencing capabilities, to assign scores to given peptide-spectrum pairs. We then evaluated the statistical power of this Casanovo score function, Casanovo-DB, to detect peptides on a benchmark of three mass spectrometry runs from three different species. Our results show that, at a 1% peptide-level false discovery rate threshold, Casanovo-DB outperforms existing hand-designed score functions by 35% to 88%. In addition, we show that re-scoring with the Percolator post-processor benefits Casanovo-DB more than other score functions, further increasing the number of detected peptides.