A phylogenetic approach to studying the roles of within-host evolution and between-host transmission of resistance for clinicalEscherichia coliinfections

Abstract

AbstractBacterial antibiotic resistance represents a public health concern that will remain relevant for the foreseeable future. Antibiotic resistant bacterial infections can occur in two ways: (1) a host is infected by a resistant bacterial strain (due to between-host transmission of resistance), or (2) a host is infected infection by a susceptible strain, followed by the de novo evolution or acquisition of resistance (due to within-host evolution of resistance). While both are critical to understanding how the evolution of resistance happens in natural settings, the relative rate at which they occur is unclear. Here, we employ phylogenetic comparative methods to examine the evolutionary dynamics of resistance inEscherichia colifor multiple common antibiotics. We report evolutionary patterns consistent with commonde novoevolution of resistance for some antibiotics and sustained transmission of resistant strains for others. For example, we observe 79 putativede novoresistance evolution events for resistance to Cefuroxime but only 31 for resistance to Ciprofloxacin, despite similar numbers of observed infections (239 and 267 respectively). We find that clusters of resistance are generally larger for Ciprofloxacin, Ceftazidima and AmoxiClav, which suggests that for these drugs, resistance is often transmitted from patient to patient. In contrast, we find that cluster sizes for resistance are generally smaller for PipTaz, Cefuroxime and Gentamicin, suggesting that resistance to these drugs is less often transmitted from patient to patient and instead evolvesde novo. In addition to differences between drugs, we also find that cluster sizes were generally larger in phylogroup B2 compared to the other phylogroups, suggesting that transmission of resistant strains is more common in this phylogroup compared to the others. Our study proposes new approaches for determining the importance ofde novoevolution or acquisition (within-host evolution) from resistance from infection with an already resistant strain (between-host transmission). Significantly, this work also bridges an important gap between evolutionary genomics and epidemiology, opening up a range of opportunities for studying the evolutionary dynamics of bacterial antibiotic resistance.