Functional analysis of variance (ANOVA) for carbon flux estimates from remote sensing data

Abstract

Abstract. The constellation of Earth-observing satellites has now produced atmospheric greenhouse gas concentration estimates covering a period of several years. Their global coverage is providing additional information on the global carbon cycle. These products can be combined with complex inversion systems to infer the magnitude of carbon sources and sinks around the globe. Multiple factors, including the atmospheric transport model and satellite product aggregation method, can impact such flux estimates. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) is a well-established statistical framework for estimating common signals while partitioning variability across factors in the analysis of experiments. Functional ANOVA extends this approach with a statistical model that incorporates spatiotemporal correlation for each ANOVA component. The approach is illustrated on inversion experiments with different satellite retrieval aggregation methods and identifies consistent significant patterns in flux increments that span large spatial scales. Functional ANOVA identifies these patterns while accounting for the uncertainty at small spatial scales that is attributed to differences in the aggregation method. Functional ANOVA is also applied to a recent flux model intercomparison project (MIP), and the relative magnitudes of inversion system effects and data source (satellite versus in situ) are similar but exhibit slightly different importance for fluxes over different continents. In all examples, the unexplained residual variability is locally sizable in magnitude but with limited spatial and temporal correlation. These common behaviors across flux inversion experiments demonstrate the diagnostic capability for functional ANOVA to simultaneously distinguish the spatiotemporal coherence of carbon cycle processes and algorithmic factors.