Comparison of amplified Q beta replicase and PCR assays for detection of Mycobacterium tuberculosis

Abstract

Because of the long time required to isolate Mycobacterium tuberculosis in culture, there is an acute need for simple rapid methods for direct detection of M. tuberculosis from human sputum specimens. We have developed and characterized quantitative manual Q beta replicase and PCR assays for M. tuberculosis. The Q beta replicase assay was based on reversible target capture of M. tuberculosis 23S rRNA followed by amplification of a replicatable detector probe with Q beta replicase. For PCR assays, primers generating a 370-bp amplification product from the IS6110 insertion element were used in combination with a control plasmid containing an internal deletion in the IS6110 amplicon. Serial dilutions of M. tuberculosis were spiked into sputum and subjected to digestion and decontamination with N-acetyl-L-cysteine and NaOH. Assay conditions were optimized for hybridization and sample processing chemistries in order to maximize sample utilization. Following assay optimization, the sensitivities of the Q beta replicase and PCR assays of spiked sputum samples were 0.5 and 5.0 CFU per assay reaction, respectively. The effects of sputum matrix on each assay were examined by testing 20 patient sputum samples which had been cultured for M. tuberculosis. The culture-positive samples included smear-positive and smear-negative samples. The results of the Q beta replicase assay were not inhibited by sputum and were in 100% agreement with those of culture, including detection of 10 culture-positive specimens. However, using an internal control plasmid coamplified with each PCR as an indicator, we detected PCR inhibition in 9 of 20 samples tested. Decreasing the amount of sample assayed in the PCR 24-fold alleviated the inhibitory effects in all but two specimens, one of which was culture positive. The decreased sample utilization also resulted in a false-negative result with a third specimen which was culture positive for M. tuberculosis. Quantitative smear results and QB replicase assay estimates of the number of organisms present in these specimens were in close agreement. The QB replicase assay performed well in comparison with both culture and PCR and should offer a rapid means for detecting and controlling infection due to M. tuberculosis.