UREMP, RO-REMP, and OO-REMP: Hybrid perturbation theories for open-shell electronic structure calculations

Abstract

An accurate description of the electron correlation energy in closed- and open-shell molecules is shown to be obtained by a second-order perturbation theory (PT) termed REMP. REMP is a hybrid of the Retaining the Excitation degree (RE) and the Møller–Plesset (MP) PTs. It performs particularly encouragingly in an orbital-optimized variant (OO-REMP) where the reference wavefunction is given by an unrestricted Slater determinant whose spin orbitals are varied such that the total energy becomes a minimum. While the approach generally behaves less satisfactorily with unrestricted Hartree–Fock references, reasonable performance is observed for restricted Hartree–Fock and restricted open-shell Hartree–Fock references. Inclusion of single excitations to OO-REMP is investigated and found—as in similar investigations—to be dissatisfying as it deteriorates performance. For the non-multireference subset of the accurate W4-11 benchmark set of Karton et al. [Chem. Phys. Lett. 510, 165–178 (2011)], OO-REMP predicts most atomization and reaction energies with chemical accuracy (1 kcal mol−1) if complete-basis-set extrapolation with augmented and core-polarized basis sets is used. For the W4-11 related test-sets, the error estimates obtained with the OO-REMP method approach those of coupled-cluster with singles, doubles and perturbative triples [CCSD(T)] within 20%–35%. The best performance of OO-REMP is found for a mixing ratio of 20%:80% MP:RE, which is essentially independent of whether radical stabilization energies, barrier heights, or reaction energies are investigated. Orbital optimization is shown to improve the REMP approach for both closed and open shell cases and outperforms coupled-cluster theory with singles and doubles (CCSD), spin-component scaled Møller-Plesset theory at second order (SCS-MP2), and density functionals, including double hybrids in all the cases considered.