Evaluating Options to Increase the Efficacy of Biocontrol Agents for the Management of Pantoea spp. Under Field Conditions

Abstract

Center rot of onion is caused by a complex of plant pathogenic Pantoea species, which can lead to significant yield losses in the field and during storage. Conventional growers use foliar protectants such as a mixture of copper bactericides and an ethylene-bis-dithiocarbamate (EBDC) fungicide to manage the disease; however, organic growers have limited management options besides copper-protectants. Biocontrol agents (BCAs) provide an alternative; however, their efficacy could be compromised due in part to their inability to colonize the foliage. We hypothesized that pretreatment with peroxide (OxiDate 2.0: a.i., hydrogen peroxide and peroxyacetic acid) enhances the colonizing ability of the subsequently applied BCAs, leading to effective center rot management. Field trials were conducted in 2020 and 2021 to assess the efficacy of peroxide, BCAs (Serenade ASO: Bacillus subtilis and BlightBan: Pseudomonas fluorescens), and an insecticide program (tank mix of spinosad and neem oil) to manage center rot. We observed no significant difference in foliar area under the disease progress curve (AUDPC) between the peroxide pretreated P. fluorescens plots and only P. fluorescens-treated plots in 2020 and 2021. Peroxide pretreatment before B. subtilis application significantly reduced the foliar AUDPC as compared with the stand-alone B. subtilis treatment in 2020; however, no such difference was observed in 2021. Similarly, peroxide pretreatment before either of the BCAs did not seem to reduce the incidence of bulb rot as compared with the stand-alone BCA treatment in any of the trials (2020 and 2021). Additionally, our foliar microbiome study showed comparatively higher P. fluorescens retention on peroxide pretreated onion foliage; however, at the end of the growing season, P. fluorescens was drastically reduced and was virtually nonexistent (<0.002% of the total reads). Overall, the pretreatment with peroxide had a limited effect in improving the foliar colonizing ability of BCAs and consequently a limited effect in managing center rot.