Progress in plant tolerance to the fungal disease Sclerotinia in breeding experiments on winter oilseed rape

Abstract

Summary Sclerotinia sclerotiorum is a pathogen which causes a disease of oilseed rape. Severe plant infection contributes to a decrease in the quality of the crop. It is therefore important to pay attention to whether hybrids are highly tolerant to this fungal disease at the early stages of breeding. In this study, the question of interest is whether there has been progress in increasing the tolerance of new hybrids to this pathogen. Three years of breeding experiments (2014, 2015, 2017) are included in the analysis. Each year, three to five experiments were carried out, with several dozen varieties and three standards. Each series of experiments was repeated in several locations. Because the degree of infection was assessed on a scale (from 1 – the highest infection – to 9 – the least infection), the analysis is carried out using an ordinal logistic model. It is noted that in earlier years the standard varieties’ probability of infection with this disease had a smaller range (empirical probability 0.5–0.83) than in the last analyzed year (empirical probability 0.33–1.00). The results of the analysis show that in 2014 and 2015 several hybrids exhibited a significantly higher tolerance to Sclerotinia, but in 2017 none of the hybrids were significantly better than the standard. Perhaps breeding selection of hybrids has eliminated the less tolerant varieties. However, to be able to draw more general conclusions, it would be necessary to repeat the study in controlled conditions (a greenhouse), where the level of fungal spores and their effect on plants could be controlled. Obtaining tolerant hybrids will enable a reduction in production costs, since there will be no need to monitor whether disease infestation occurs and no need to use corresponding plant protection products.