Ensembles generated from crystal structures of single distant homologues solve challenging molecular-replacement cases inAMPLE

Abstract

Molecular replacement (MR) is the predominant route to solution of the phase problem in macromolecular crystallography. Although routine in many cases, it becomes more effortful and often impossible when the available experimental structures typically used as search models are only distantly homologous to the target. Nevertheless, with current powerful MR software, relatively small core structures shared between the target and known structure, of 20–40% of the overall structure for example, can succeed as search models where they can be isolated. Manual sculpting of such small structural cores is rarely attempted and is dependent on the crystallographer's expertise and understanding of the protein family in question. Automated search-model editing has previously been performed on the basis of sequence alignment, in order to eliminate, for example, side chains or loops that are not present in the target, or on the basis of structural features (e.g.solvent accessibility) or crystallographic parameters (e.g.Bfactors). Here, based on recent work demonstrating a correlation between evolutionary conservation and protein rigidity/packing, novel automated ways to derive edited search models from a given distant homologue over a range of sizes are presented. A variety of structure-based metrics, many readily obtained from online webservers, can be fed to the MR pipelineAMPLEto produce search models that succeed with a set of test cases where expertly manually edited comparators, further processed in diverse ways withMrBUMP, fail. Further significant performance gains result when the structure-based distance geometry methodCONCOORDis used to generate ensembles from the distant homologue. To our knowledge, this is the first such approach whereby a single structure is meaningfully transformed into an ensemble for the purposes of MR. Additional cases further demonstrate the advantages of the approach.CONCOORDis freely available and computationally inexpensive, so these novel methods offer readily available new routes to solve difficult MR cases.