MRI for paediatric flatfoot: is it necessary?

Abstract

Objective: To determine the additional benefit of MRI for children with flatfoot deformity assessed with weight-bearing radiographs in a specialist paediatric orthopaedic unit. Methods and materials: Patient cohort was obtained by searching the Radiology Information System for children referred for investigation of flatfoot. All patients with flatfoot on weight-bearing radiographs who had undergone MRI were included. Radiographs were classified by a consultant musculoskeletal radiologist as showing no underlying abnormality, talo-calcaneal coalition, calcaneonavicular coalition, accessory navicular or other abnormality. MRI studies were classified similarly by a different consultant musculoskeletal radiologist blinded to the radiographic findings. Results: 33 males and 24 females were included (mean age 12.5 years; range 3–18 years). 24 had bilateral abnormality, so 81 feet were assessed. Radiographs showed no specific abnormality (n = 51), talocalcaneal coalition (n = 6), calcaneonavicular coalition (n = 3), os naviculare (n = 12) or other abnormality (n = 9). MRI showed no specific abnormality (n = 40), talocalcaneal coalition (n = 10), calcaneonavicular coalition (n = 5), os naviculare (n = 12) or other abnormality (n = 14). Assuming MRI as the diagnostic gold-standard, additional relevant diagnostic information was identified in 19 (23.5%) cases, while in the 51 cases for which radiographs provided no specific diagnosis MRI confirmed no underlying abnormality in 31 (60.8%). Conclusion: MRI is a valuable adjunct to weight-bearing radiography for investigating paediatric flatfoot deformity. Advances in knowledge: MRI is of value in the assessment of paediatric flatfoot, additional diagnostic information to radiography being identified in 23.5% cases, while in 60.8% of cases for which radiographs provided no specific diagnosis MRI confirmed no underlying abnormality.