The Impact of Surgeon Experience on Surgical Parameters and Complication Rates for the Surgical Management of Adult Spinal Deformities: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Abstract

The surgical management of adult spinal deformities (ASDs) involves a wide variety of complex and technically challenging operative techniques. Despite numerous publications examining the relationship between surgeon experience and outcomes in ASD, no systematic review or meta-analysis exists. This first-time systematic review and meta-analysis examines the impact of surgeon experience on the surgical parameters and complication rates for the surgical management of ASD. Four databases were used for the initial search of this study from database inception until 22 September 2023. The inclusion criteria required articles that examined the outcomes for surgery for ASD, stratified outcomes by surgeon experience and/or the learning curve as a proxy for surgeon experience, and utilized adult patients (>18 years of age). Seven articles met the criteria for final inclusion. Patients in the Experienced Surgeon group had statistically significantly lower levels of EBL with no significant difference in operative time after surgery for ASD compared to patients in the Inexperienced Surgeon group via a meta-analysis of three articles. Patients in the Experienced Surgeon group had a statistically significantly lower total complication rate compared to patients in the Inexperienced Surgeon group via a meta-analysis. Increased surgeon experience resulted in lower levels of EBL, without a significant difference in the operative time after surgery for ASD.