A Longitudinal Study: Microbiological Quality of Raw Beef from Halal and Non-Halal Meat Markets in the United States

Abstract

Halal means permissible according to Islamic law. Halal meat is obtained by hand slaughtering an animal that is not stunned and that is blessed by a Muslim individual immediately before slaughter. The purpose of this study was to determine the microbiological quality of raw meat from halal meat markets. A total of 138 beef samples were purchased from three halal (n = 72 samples) and three non-halal markets (n = 66 samples) between November 2016 and October 2017. All samples were analyzed for the presence of indicator organisms—aerobic plate counts (APCs), Enterobacteriaceae counts (ECs), total coliform counts (TCCs), and generic Escherichia coli (ECCs). The levels of APCs, ECs, TCCs, and ECCs (mean log CFU/g) in halal samples were 4.93 (100%), 2.89 (91.7%), 2.87 (94.4%), and 1.09 (18.1%), respectively, and those in non-halal samples were 4.92 (100%), 3.07 (95.5%), 3.02 (89.4%), and 1.15 (16.7%), respectively. The levels of TCCs and ECs were higher in halal samples during the summer compared to the other three seasons, whereas the highest ECCs in halal samples were found during autumn. In non-halal samples, significant differences were observed in the ECCs, TCCs, and ECs across seasons, with the highest level of contamination during autumn. Samples having higher levels of indicator organisms (APCs, ECs, TCCs, and ECCs) were more likely to be positive for pathogenic bacteria. The high levels of indicator organisms in both halal and non-halal retail meat samples suggest that the operation size, and not halal or non-halal meat classification, is associated with the microbiological quality. These findings can inform food safety interventions targeting small meat markets in the United States.