Ensemble of Below-Cloud Scavenging Models for Assessing the Uncertainty Characteristics in Wet Raindrop Deposition Modeling

Abstract

This work is devoted to the development of an ensemble of below-cloud scavenging models of pollutant aerosol transport into the atmosphere. Among other factors contributing to the uncertainty of the forecasts of the dispersion and deposition of technogenic gas-aerosol releases in the atmosphere, precipitation scavenging is one of the least studied and, in case of precipitation, can be the dominant mechanism for aerosol deposition. To form the ensemble of below-cloud scavenging models, appropriate experimental data, raindrop-aerosol capture models, raindrop terminal velocity parameterizations, and raindrop size distributions were chosen. The pool of models was prepared and then evaluated to adequately describe the experimental data using statistical analysis. Rank diagrams were used to analyze the adequacy of meteorological ensembles; together with the ensemble distribution construction, they allowed selecting the groups of models with such properties as to produce unbiased estimates and dispersion corresponding to the dispersion of the experimental data. The model calculations of the concentration fraction deposited due to below-cloud scavenging were performed using a log-normal distribution with characteristics corresponding to those observed during the accidents at the Chernobyl NPP and Fukushima-1 NPP. The results were compared with those obtained using the models of the NAME and FLEXPART codes. The results of this work can be used to improve the current approaches applied for modelling the distribution of pollutants in the atmosphere in the case of emergency, enhancing the reliability of forecasts by taking into account uncertainties in the results. The formed multi-model ensemble will be included in the decision support system used in responding to releases of radioactive substances into the atmosphere.