Viscoelastic Reversibility of Carrageenan Hydrogels under Large Amplitude Oscillatory Shear: Hybrid Carrageenans versus Blends

Abstract

The viscoelastic response of carrageenan hydrogels to large amplitude oscillatory shear (LAOS) has not received much attention in the literature in spite of its relevance in industrial application. A set of hybrid carrageenans with differing chemical compositions are gelled in the presence of KCl or NaCl, and their nonlinear viscoelastic responses are systematically compared with mixtures of kappa- and iota-carrageenans of equivalent kappa-carrageenan contents. Two categories of LAOS response are identified: strain softening and strain hardening gels. Strain softening gels show LAOS non-reversibility: when entering the nonlinear viscoelastic regime, the shear storage modulus G′ decreases with increasing strain, and never recovers its linear value G0 after successive LAOS sweeps. In contrast to this, strain hardening carrageenan gels show a certain amount of LAOS reversibility: when entering the nonlinear regime, G′ increases with strain and shows a maximum at strain γH. For strains applied below γH, G0 shows good reversibility and the strain hardening behavior is maintained. For strains larger than γH, G0 decreases significantly indicating an irreversible structural change in the elastic network. Strain hardening and elastic recovery after LAOS prevail for hybrid carrageenan and iota-carrageenan gels, but are only achieved when blends are gelled in NaCl, suggesting a phase separated structure with a certain degree of co-aggregated interface for mixed gels.