Abstract
In this article, we discuss a number of challenges with the empirical study of emotion and its relation to moral judgment. We examine a case study involving the moral foreign-language effect, according to which people show an increased utilitarian response tendency in moral dilemmas when using their non-native language. One important proposed explanation for this effect is that using one’s non-native language reduces emotional arousal, and that reduced emotion is responsible for this tendency. We offer reasons to think that there is insufficient evidence for accepting this explanation at present. We argue that there are three themes that constrain our current ability to draw firm empirical conclusions: 1) the frequent use of proxies or partial measures for emotions, 2) the lack of a predictive and generalizable theory of emotion and specific emotion-types, and 3) the obscurity of a baseline level of neutrality with respect to participant emotion. These lessons apply not only to research on the moral foreign-language effect, but to empirical research in moral psychology more generally.
Reference50 articles.
1. Bago B., De Neys W. (2019), “The Intuitive Greater Good: Testing the Corrective Dual Process Model of Moral Cognition,” Journal of Experimental Psychology: General 148 (10): 1782–1801.
2. Baron J., Gürçay B., Luce M.F. (2018), “Correlations of Trait and State Emotions with Utilitarian Moral Judgements,” Cognition and Emotion 32 (1): 116–129.
3. Batson C.D., Coke J.S., Chard F. et al (1979), “Generality of the ‘Glow of Goodwill’: Effectsof Mood on Helping and Information Acquisition,” Social Psychology Quarterly 42 (2): 176–179.
4. Białek M., De Neys W. (2016), “Conflict Detection During Moral Decision-Making: Evidence for Deontic Reasoners’ Utilitarian Sensitivity,” Journal of Cognitive Psychology 28 (5): 631–639.
5. Białek M., De Neys W. (2017), “Dual Processes and Moral Conflict: Evidence for Deontological Reasoners’ Intuitive Utilitarian Sensitivity,” Judgment and Decision Making 12 (2): 148–167.
Cited by
9 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献，注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献，订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献