Stream size‐dependent effect of urban land use on occupancy of an apex freshwater carnivore recolonizing past ranges

Abstract

AbstractAccurate assessment of population trends and factors that limit distributions of threatened species is key to conserving biodiversity. A reduction in impacts of human land use on species habitats may be one of the factors involved in the recolonization of former ranges by native species. The signature of this process could be detected as a temporal reduction of land use effects on species distributions, or as a spatial reduction, with effects persisting only in habitats more sensitive to anthropogenic stressors. We explored these hypotheses in a recolonizing semiaquatic carnivore. Our species of interest was the Eurasian river otter (Lutra lutra) in Italy, a nationally vulnerable species with a restricted but expanding range. Human land use is likely to strongly affect riparian and stream communities through habitat degradation. We used three independent survey datasets collected in 2003, 2009, and 2019 at the southern range periphery, and unpaired‐site occupancy models to account for imperfect detection in otter surveys. To assess how land use affects recolonization by otters, we tested three main model predictions: (1) occupancy increased over years, (2) effects of agricultural and urban land cover on occupancy decreased over years, (3) effects of agricultural and urban land cover were constant across years and changed with stream size and elevation. We found evidence that otter occupancy increased over years, with predicted mean occupancy of 0.27 in 2003 and 0.65 in 2019. An interaction effect of urban land cover with stream size was the strongest predictor of otter occupancy. Interestingly, a higher percentage of urban land cover around streams was predicted to reduce the probability of occupancy at smaller streams, but did not influence occupancy at larger streams. Despite a large increase in occupancy, otters at the southern periphery of the Italian range are still unable to colonize small rivers in urbanized areas. This pattern supports our hypothesis that human land use can affect recolonizing species at sensitive habitats, considering the intrinsic vulnerability of small stream ecosystems to anthropogenic stressors. Restoring small streams impacted by urban areas can be a valuable conservation action to increase habitat connectivity and favor recolonization of otters.