Tribe or Not? Critical Inspection of Group Differences Using TribalGram

Abstract

With the rise of AI and data mining techniques, group profiling and group-level analysis have been increasingly used in many domains, including policy making and direct marketing. In some cases, the statistics extracted from data may provide insights to a group’s shared characteristics; in others, the group-level analysis can lead to problems, including stereotyping and systematic oppression. How can analytic tools facilitate a more conscientious process in group analysis? In this work, we identify a set of accountable group analytics design guidelines to explicate the needs for group differentiation and preventing overgeneralization of a group. Following the design guidelines, we develop TribalGram , a visual analytic suite that leverages interpretable machine learning algorithms and visualization to offer inference assessment, model explanation, data corroboration, and sense-making. Through the interviews with domain experts, we showcase how our design and tools can bring a richer understanding of “groups” mined from the data.