Affiliation:
1. School of Criminal Justice Rutgers University–Newark Newark New Jersey USA
2. Department of Statistics University of Florida Gainesville Florida USA
3. Department of Sociology City University of New York Graduate Center New York New York USA
Abstract
AbstractResearch SummaryFollowing high‐profile police killings, many U.S. cities banned officers from using chokeholds and other neck restraints. The evidence for such bans, however, is limited. To test whether use‐of‐force policies prohibiting neck restraints are related to fewer police killings, we use three modeling approaches to analyze 2183 U.S. cities between 2009 and 2021. Police killings were lower in places that adopted neck‐restraint bans and the bans were associated with less crime and fewer assaults on officers, net of controls. Because officer labor unions can affect use‐of‐force policies and the frequency of police killings, we also analyzed them, finding unionization increased the likelihood a city had a neck‐restraint ban and had a null or negative association with police killings.Policy ImplicationsAdopting a neck‐restraint ban is likely an effective way to reduce deaths due to police use of force with minimal collateral consequences. The bans operate through a diffuse discouragement of many types of lethal force or as a part of an array of use‐of‐force policies. Their direct relationship to asphyxiation deaths remains unclear. Officer unionization is unlikely to change the frequency of police killings, except through its association with stricter use‐of‐force policies.
Subject
Law,Public Administration
Reference103 articles.
1. Police use of force: An analysis of organizational characteristics
2. The Effects of Police Violence on Inner-City Students*
3. Ba B. Kaplan J. Knox D. Komisarchik M. Lanzalotto G. Mariman R. Mummolo J. Rivera R. &Torres M.(2023).Political diversity in U.S. police agencies. Working paper.https://jmummolo.scholar.princeton.edu/sites/g/files/toruqf3341/files/documents/ba_et_al_2023.pdf
4. Less-Than-Lethal Weapons and Police-Citizen Killings in U.S. Urban Areas