Improvements to Reservoir Material-Balance Methods

Abstract

Summary Experience with material-balance data sets from the field and from simulation has revealed some procedures that can be used to improve analysis of both oil and gas reservoirs: Failure to account for a weak waterdrive can result in significant material-balance errors. The assertion of previous authors that weak waterdrive exhibits a negative slope on the Cole (gas) and Campbell (oil) plots has been confirmed. A weak waterdrive is much more unambiguous on these plots than on commonly used plots, such as the p/z plot for gas. A modified version of the Cole plot is proposed to account for formation compressibility. The reservoir drive indices are a useful tool for determining the correctness of the material-balance solution because they must sum to unity. The drive indices should never be normalized to sum to unity because this obscures their usefulness and leads to a false sense of security. A modified version of the Roach plot (for gas) is proposed that improves interpretation in some waterdrive situations. Material balance has not been replaced by reservoir simulation; rather, it is complementary to simulation and can provide valuable insights to reservoir performance that cannot be obtained by simulation.