Distinctive pattern of sequence polymorphism in the NS3 protein of hepatitis C virus type 1b reflects conflicting evolutionary pressures

Abstract

Analysis of complete polyprotein-encoding sequences of hepatitis C virus genotype 1b (HCV-1b) showed evidence not only of past purifying selection but also of abundant slightly deleterious non-synonymous variants subject to ongoing purifying selection. The NS3 protein (with protease and NTPase/helicase activity) revealed less evidence of purifying selection acting on the cytotoxic T cells (CTL) epitopes than did the other proteins, whereas outside the CTL epitopes NS3 was more conserved than the other proteins. Moreover, NS3 showed a high incidence of forward-and-backward or parallel non-synonymous changes in CTL epitopes, as measured by the consistency index across the phylogeny of HCV-1b genomes computed at non-singleton non-synonymous polymorphic sites. This result implies that certain non-synonymous mutations have recurred frequently throughout the phylogeny in the codons encoding the epitopes in NS3. This pattern is most easily explained by the frequent re-occurrence of the same set of escape mutations in CTL epitopes of NS3, which are selectively favoured within hosts expressing the presenting class I major histocompatibility complex molecule, but are subject to purifying selection at the population level. The fact that this pattern is most strikingly observed in the case of NS3 suggests that the evolutionary conflict between immune escape and functional constraint on the protein is more acute in the case of NS3 than any of the other proteins of HCV-1b.