Uncertainty estimation for ensemble particle image velocimetry

Abstract

Abstract We present a novel approach to estimate the uncertainty in ensemble particle image velocimetry (PIV) measurements. The ensemble PIV technique is widely used when the cross-correlation signal-to-noise ratio is insufficient to perform a reliable instantaneous velocity measurement. Despite the utility of ensemble PIV, uncertainty quantification for this type of measurement has not been studied. Here, we propose a method for estimating the uncertainty directly from the probability density function of displacements found by deconvolving the ensemble cross-correlation from the ensemble autocorrelation. We then find the second moment of the probability density function and apply a scaling factor to report the uncertainty in the velocity measurement. We call this method the moment of probability of displacement (MPD). We assess MPD’s performance with synthetic and experimental images. We show that predicted uncertainties agree well with the expected root mean square (RMS) of the error in the velocity measurements over a wide range of image and flow conditions. MPD shows good sensitivity to various PIV error sources with around 86% accuracy in matching the RMS of the error in the baseline data sets. So, MPD establishes itself as a reliable uncertainty quantification algorithm for ensemble PIV. We compared the results of MPD against one of the existing instantaneous PIV uncertainty approaches, moment of correlation (MC). We adapted the MC approach for ensemble PIV, however, its primary limitations remain the assumption of the Gaussian probability density function of displacements and the Gaussian particles’ intensity profile. In addition, our analysis shows that ensemble MC consistently underestimates the uncertainty, while MPD outperforms that and removes the limiting Gaussian assumption for the particle and probability density function, thus overcoming the limitations of MC.