Differences in spatial versus temporal reaction norms for spring and autumn phenological events
-
Published:2020-11-23
Issue:49
Volume:117
Page:31249-31258
-
ISSN:0027-8424
-
Container-title:Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
-
language:en
-
Short-container-title:Proc Natl Acad Sci USA
Author:
Delgado Maria del MarORCID, Roslin TomasORCID, Tikhonov Gleb, Meyke EvgeniyORCID, Lo Coong, Gurarie EliezerORCID, Abadonova Marina, Abduraimov OzodbekORCID, Adrianova Olga, Akimova TatianaORCID, Akkiev MuzhigitORCID, Ananin AleksandrORCID, Andreeva Elena, Andriychuk Natalia, Antipin Maxim, Arzamascev Konstantin, Babina Svetlana, Babushkin Miroslav, Bakin Oleg, Barabancova Anna, Basilskaja Inna, Belova Nina, Belyaeva Natalia, Bespalova TatjanaORCID, Bisikalova Evgeniya, Bobretsov Anatoly, Bobrov VladimirORCID, Bobrovskyi Vadim, Bochkareva ElenaORCID, Bogdanov Gennady, Bolshakov Vladimir, Bondarchuk SvetlanaORCID, Bukharova EvgeniyaORCID, Butunina Alena, Buyvolov YuriORCID, Buyvolova AnnaORCID, Bykov Yuri, Chakhireva Elena, Chashchina OlgaORCID, Cherenkova NadezhdaORCID, Chistjakov Sergej, Chuhontseva Svetlana, Davydov Evgeniy A.ORCID, Demchenko ViktorORCID, Diadicheva ElenaORCID, Dobrolyubov Aleksandr, Dostoyevskaya Ludmila, Drovnina SvetlanaORCID, Drozdova Zoya, Dubanaev Akynaly, Dubrovsky YuriyORCID, Elsukov Sergey, Epova LidiaORCID, Ermakova Olga S., Ermakova Olga, Esengeldenova Aleksandra, Evstigneev Oleg, Fedchenko Irina, Fedotova Violetta, Filatova Tatiana, Gashev SergeyORCID, Gavrilov Anatoliy, Gaydysh IrinaORCID, Golovcov Dmitrij, Goncharova Nadezhda, Gorbunova Elena, Gordeeva Tatyana, Grishchenko VitalyORCID, Gromyko Ludmila, Hohryakov Vladimir, Hritankov Alexander, Ignatenko Elena, Igosheva Svetlana, Ivanova Uliya, Ivanova NatalyaORCID, Kalinkin YuryORCID, Kaygorodova Evgeniya, Kazansky Fedor, Kiseleva Darya, Knorre AnastasiaORCID, Kolpashikov Leonid, Korobov Evgenii, Korolyova Helen, Korotkikh NataliaORCID, Kosenkov Gennadiy, Kossenko Sergey, Kotlugalyamova Elvira, Kozlovsky EvgenyORCID, Kozsheechkin Vladimir, Kozurak Alla, Kozyr Irina, Krasnopevtseva Aleksandra, Kruglikov Sergey, Kuberskaya Olga, Kudryavtsev Aleksey, Kulebyakina Elena, Kulsha Yuliia, Kupriyanova Margarita, Kurbanbagamaev Murad, Kutenkov Anatoliy, Kutenkova Nadezhda, Kuyantseva Nadezhda, Kuznetsov Andrey, Larin EvgeniyORCID, Lebedev PavelORCID, Litvinov Kirill, Luzhkova Natalia, Mahmudov Azizbek, Makovkina Lidiya, Mamontov Viktor, Mayorova Svetlana, Megalinskaja Irina, Meydus ArturORCID, Minin AleksandrORCID, Mitrofanov Oleg, Motruk Mykhailo, Myslenkov Aleksandr, Nasonova NinaORCID, Nemtseva Natalia, Nesterova Irina, Nezdoliy Tamara, Niroda Tatyana, Novikova Tatiana, Panicheva Darya, Pavlov Alexey, Pavlova Klara, Van Polina, Podolski Sergei, Polikarpova Natalja, Polyanskaya Tatiana, Pospelov IgorORCID, Pospelova Elena, Prokhorov IlyaORCID, Prokosheva Irina, Puchnina Lyudmila, Putrashyk Ivan, Raiskaya JuliaORCID, Rozhkov YuriORCID, Rozhkova Olga, Rudenko Marina, Rybnikova Irina, Rykova Svetlana, Sahnevich Miroslava, Samoylov Alexander, Sanko Valeri, Sapelnikova Inna, Sazonov Sergei, Selyunina Zoya, Shalaeva Ksenia, Shashkov Maksim, Shcherbakov Anatoliy, Shevchyk Vasyl, Shubin Sergej, Shujskaja Elena, Sibgatullin Rustam, Sikkila Natalia, Sitnikova Elena, Sivkov Andrei, Skok Nataliya, Skorokhodova Svetlana, Smirnova Elena, Sokolova Galina, Sopin Vladimir, Spasovski Yurii, Stepanov Sergei, Stratiy Vitalіy, Strekalovskaya Violetta, Sukhov Alexander, Suleymanova GuzalyaORCID, Sultangareeva Lilija, Teleganova Viktorija, Teplov Viktor, Teplova Valentina, Tertitsa Tatiana, Timoshkin Vladislav, Tirski Dmitry, Tolmachev Andrej, Tomilin Aleksey, Tselishcheva Ludmila, Turgunov MirabdullaORCID, Tyukh Yurij, Van Vladimir, Ershkova ElenaORCID, Vasin Aleksander, Vasina Aleksandra, Vekliuk Anatoliy, Vetchinnikova LidiaORCID, Vinogradov VladislavORCID, Volodchenkov Nikolay, Voloshina InnaORCID, Xoliqov Tura, Yablonovska-Grishchenko Eugenia, Yakovlev Vladimir, Yakovleva Marina, Yantser OksanaORCID, Yarema Yurij, Zahvatov Andrey, Zakharov Valery, Zelenetskiy Nicolay, Zheltukhin Anatolii, Zubina Tatyana, Kurhinen JuriORCID, Ovaskainen OtsoORCID
Abstract
For species to stay temporally tuned to their environment, they use cues such as the accumulation of degree-days. The relationships between the timing of a phenological event in a population and its environmental cue can be described by a population-level reaction norm. Variation in reaction norms along environmental gradients may either intensify the environmental effects on timing (cogradient variation) or attenuate the effects (countergradient variation). To resolve spatial and seasonal variation in species’ response, we use a unique dataset of 91 taxa and 178 phenological events observed across a network of 472 monitoring sites, spread across the nations of the former Soviet Union. We show that compared to local rates of advancement of phenological events with the advancement of temperature-related cues (i.e., variation within site over years), spatial variation in reaction norms tend to accentuate responses in spring (cogradient variation) and attenuate them in autumn (countergradient variation). As a result, among-population variation in the timing of events is greater in spring and less in autumn than if all populations followed the same reaction norm regardless of location. Despite such signs of local adaptation, overall phenotypic plasticity was not sufficient for phenological events to keep exact pace with their cues—the earlier the year, the more did the timing of the phenological event lag behind the timing of the cue. Overall, these patterns suggest that differences in the spatial versus temporal reaction norms will affect species’ response to climate change in opposite ways in spring and autumn.
Publisher
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
Subject
Multidisciplinary
Cited by
22 articles.
订阅此论文施引文献
订阅此论文施引文献,注册后可以免费订阅5篇论文的施引文献,订阅后可以查看论文全部施引文献
|
|