Observing competence in CBT supervision: a systematic review of the available instruments

Abstract

AbstractGovernment policy, like evaluations of clinical practice, indicates the growing importance of supervision in fostering practitioner development and in improving the fidelity of therapies. However, instruments with which to measure competent supervision are often problematic, thereby hampering these key activities (e.g. they are rare, rely on self-ratings by participants, and psychometric data can be limited). To contribute to progress, this paper reviews the current options for measuring competent clinical supervision by means of direct observation, a favoured approach within cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT). We systematically reviewed 10 existing instruments that were designed to observe and quantify competent supervision, focusing on three broad criteria for sound measurement (i.e. an instrument's Design, Implementation, and Yield: DIY). Suggestions for future research on instruments that can fulfil the functions that are provided distinctively through direct observation are outlined.