Direct numerical simulation of the incompressible temporally developing turbulent boundary layer

Abstract

We perform a direct numerical simulation (DNS) investigation of the incompressible temporally developing turbulent boundary layer. The approach is inspired by temporal simulations of flows which are generally thought of as developing in space, such as wakes and mixing layers. Compressible boundary layers have previously been studied in this manner yet the temporal approach appears to be under-exploited in the literature concerning incompressible boundary layers. The flow is the turbulent counterpart to the laminar Rayleigh problem or Stokes’ first problem, in which a fluid at rest is set into motion by a wall moving at constant velocity. An initial profile that models the effect of a wall-mounted trip wire is implemented and allows the characterisation of initial conditions by a trip Reynolds number. For the current set-up, a trip Reynolds number of 500 based on the trip-wire diameter successfully triggers transition yet only mildly perturbs the flow so it assumes a natural development at the lowest possible Reynolds number based on momentum thickness. A systematic trip study reveals that as the ratio of momentum thickness to trip-wire diameter approaches unity, our flow approaches a state free from the effects of its starting trip Reynolds number. The transport of a passive scalar by this flow is also simulated. The role played by domain size is investigated with two boxes, sized to accommodate two chosen final Reynolds numbers. Comparisons of the skin friction coefficient, velocity and scalar statistics demonstrate that the temporally developing boundary layer is a good model for the spatially developing boundary layer once initial conditions can be neglected. Analysis of similarity solutions suggests such a rapprochement of the spatial and temporal boundary layers may be expected at high Reynolds numbers given that the only terms that asymptotically persist are those common to both cases. If one seeks statistics for the turbulent boundary layer, the temporal boundary layer is therefore a viable method if modest convergence is sufficient. We suggest that such a temporal set-up could prove useful in the study of turbulence dynamics.