Extending the concepts of response spectrum analysis to nonlinear static analysis: Does it make sense?

Abstract

AbstractThe study presented in this paper aims to assess the recent novelties proposed by new generation building codes about the extension of some concepts at the base of linear analyses to the procedures of nonlinear static analysis. The nonlinear static analysis (pushover) is an extensively adopted approach by engineers and practitioners for purpose of assessing the seismic performance of new and existing buildings, although several drawbacks characterize this methodology, as evidenced by the existing scientific literature. In order to overcome the well-known limitations characterizing nonlinear static analysis, and to offer an alternative to nonlinear dynamic analysis, the recent upgrades of some building codes, such as the Italian one, provide different rules to employ in nonlinear static procedures. Among these new provisions, one regards the possibility to use a horizontal load profile proportional to the storey forces derived from a response spectrum analysis in all cases (i.e., also for irregular buildings). The main goal of this study is to demonstrate the reliability of this new load profile when strong irregularities arise. To this scope, the seismic behaviour of a sample of archetype buildings characterized by increasing in-height irregularity was investigated. The sample of buildings was subdivided in two subsets characterized by different design levels, one conceived by considering the prescriptions of the new Italian building code and one designed according to the oldest Italian building code (i.e., without considering anti-seismic details). The sample of buildings, simulating new and existing cases, was firstly modelled and after investigated through nonlinear static analyses by employing both traditional (i.e., inverse triangular- and uniform-like) and new (i.e., derived from response spectrum analysis) load profiles. After, nonlinear dynamic analyses were run, in order to assess the capacity of both traditional and new load profiles to capture the dynamic behaviour of the investigated archetype buildings. The performed analysis campaign demonstrated the efficiency of the new load profile proposed by the code, and the output of the work provided an answer to the main question posed by the authors: does it make sense to extend the concepts of response spectrum analysis to nonlinear static analysis?