Recommended Stress Formulae for Tubular Conical Transition Designs

Abstract

Abstract For the design of tubular conical transitions, the axial, bending, and hoop stresses at the junctions are required. Among the offshore design standards, API RP-2A, ISO 19902, and NORSOK N-004, various equations exist for the same stress quantity which may cause confusions. The quality of these existing stress formulae will be examined in this paper. The tubular conical stress equations used in the offshore industry started from Boardman’s studies in the 1940s. Recently, Lotsberg re-formulated this problem and applied the results to stress concentration factor (SCF) applications. This paper solves the same set of shell equations but the formulations are cast in a different form. This new format allows for an in-depth examination of existing code equations. In addition, the formulation as presented can be used for modifications to gain higher accuracy. Several recommended new stress formulae are provided. It is observed that the existing code provisions’ accuracy quickly deteriorates for cases where plate thickness in tubular and cone differ. The recommended approach is based on theoretical framework of shell mechanics, which better facilitate tubular/cone force balances when compared with existing equations. The sectional relationships among moment, shear, and hoop loads are also treated consistently using shell theory. The resulted improvements make the recommended formulae more accurate than the existing provisions.