Deep-penetrating spudcan foundations on layered clays: numerical analysis

Abstract

This paper presents results of large deformation finite element (LDFE) analyses that investigate the penetration response of deep-penetrating spudcan foundations in stratified soil comprising a strong clay layer overlying weaker clay. Such strength profiles give rise to potential punch-through failure, with a local maximum penetration resistance followed by some reduction. The paper is a companion paper to one that presents results from centrifuge model tests of the same problem, with the overall aim being to investigate the potential for punch-through failure and its severity, as a basis for improving design methods for evaluating spudcan penetration. The LDFE analyses have simulated continuous penetration of smooth and rough spudcan foundations from the sea-bed surface. A detailed parametric study has been undertaken, exploring the relevant range of layer thickness (relative to the spudcan diameter), strength ratios and spudcan base roughness. The results have been validated against previously published results and the centrifuge test data presented in a companion paper. Excellent agreement was obtained between the results from LDFE analyses and centrifuge tests. As the ratio of the shear strength of the bottom layer to that of the top layer decreased, upwards soil flow around the spudcan shoulder became less pronounced and the failure mechanism was dominated by a steep-sided plug of soil from the top layer being forced deep into the lower layer. The potential for severe punch-through was demonstrated by a significant reduction in the resistance profile as the spudcan approached the interface between the two layers. A preliminary design chart is proposed to estimate the cavity depth above the penetrating spudcan, which was significantly greater than that for a single layer clay. The penetration responses have been presented in terms of profiles of normalised net bearing pressure for a range of layer geometries and soil properties. Potential punch-through occurred for all cases where the strength ratio was less than or equal to 0·6, with the reduction in resistance being greater the lower the strength ratio of the underlying layer to the upper layer, and the thicker the upper layer, but reducing as the strength gradient in the lower layer increased. The current approach suggested in offshore design guidelines is shown to underestimate the penetration resistance significantly, in most cases, and give poor estimates of the likelihood and severity of spudcan punch-through.