The Mono-Prep system increases the detection rate of sputum smear microscopy for diagnosing tuberculosis

Abstract

Objective Direct sputum smear microscopy (DSSM) has a low detection rate. This study investigated whether an alternative method called Mono-Prep smear microscopy (MPSM) can enhance the diagnosis of tuberculosis in tuberculosis laboratories that perform direct smear microscopy in China. Methods A total of 117 sputum samples were collected from outpatients who attended Beijing Chest Hospital. DSSM, MPSM, solid culture, and Xpert MTB/RIF were performed on the samples. Results The positive rates of DSSM, MPSM, solid culture, and Xpert MTB/RIF were 27.4% (32/117), 40.2% (47/117), 35.9% (42/117), and 52.1% (61/117), respectively. MPSM could detect 15 more cases of tuberculosis compared with DSSM (47 vs 32) among 117 sputum samples. This represented a significantly higher positive rate and sensitivity of MPSM compared with DSSM. However, MPSM appeared to have a lower specificity (81.3%) compared with DSSM (90.7%) with the solid culture used as a standard. Conclusion Use of MPSM can increase the number of positive sputum samples, but it still needs improvement.