Extralaryngeal Spread in Total Laryngectomy: Comparing the Need for Thyroidectomy

Abstract

Objective: At our institution, thyroid preservation during total laryngectomy (TL) varies by surgeon, offering a distinctive dataset to compare disease outcomes in TL patients with or without thyroidectomy. Methods: This retrospective chart review study, conducted at a tertiary referral medical center, comprises patients who underwent TL for laryngeal or hypopharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma from 2014 to 2022. The study includes data on patient demographics, surgeries, pathological staging, tumor subsites, thyroid involvement, and adjuvant therapy. Results: In this study, 147 patients, mostly male (83%) and white (82%), were included. Surgeries comprised 60 hemi thyroidectomies, 35 total or completion thyroidectomies, 48 without thyroid removal, and 4 isthmusectomies. Data analysis compared these 4 groups and the cohort of no thyroid removal (NT) versus any thyroidectomy (T = 99). Among the 99 patients, 27 showed positive gland involvement, primarily due to direct disease extension (26 cases). No significant difference was found in recurrence rates or recurrence-related mortality among the 4 groups or between NT and T ( P = .156). However, there was a significant difference in T staging and prognostic staging among the groups and between NT versus T ( P = .043). The NT cohort showed a higher likelihood of being T3, while T was more likely to be T4. Conclusion: We found no significant difference in recurrence rates or mortality between TL patients with or without thyroid removal. However, those without thyroid removal often had lower T stages. Notably, 27% of thyroidectomy patients had gland invasion, highlighting the importance of thyroid removal in TL.