Receiver operating characteristic estimation and threshold selection criteria in three-class classification problems for clustered data

Abstract

Statistical evaluation of diagnostic tests, and, more generally, of biomarkers, is a constantly developing field, in which complexity of the assessment increases with the complexity of the design under which data are collected. One particularly prevalent type of data is clustered data, where individual units are naturally nested into clusters. In these cases, Bias can arise from omission, in the evaluation process, of cluster-level effects and/or individual covariates. Focusing on the three-class case and for continuous-valued diagnostic tests, we investigate how to exploit the clustered structure of data within a linear-mixed model approach, both when the assumption of normality holds and when it does not. We provide a method for the estimation of covariate-specific receiver operating characteristic surfaces and discuss methods for the choice of optimal thresholds, proposing three possible estimators. A proof of consistency and asymptotic normality of the proposed threshold estimators is given. All considered methods are evaluated by extensive simulation experiments. As an application, we study the use of the Lysosomal Associated Membrane Protein Family Member 5 gene expression as a biomarker to distinguish among three types of glutamatergic neurons.