Affiliation:
1. Salt River, Cape Town, Western Cape, South Africa
Abstract
What to do with colonial-era monuments has been a major challenge facing southern African nations ever since the demise of colonialism and apartheid in the subregion. To deal with the problem, governments in the region embarked on popular transformative agendas that included decontextualization and the removal of alleged problematic monuments from the public sphere. Such approaches have over the years received the backing of several scholars of heritage and history, who have often cited them as ones capable of offering ever-ending solutions to the issue. However, while recognizing the necessity of transformation, this article nevertheless argues that such a transformative agenda that is characterized by erasures of that which has been accepted as heritage in a particular phase of a country’s history is not a proper way of dealing with such symbols. First, such approaches create possibilities for heritage fundamentalism to filter into the domain of heritage. Second, such approaches were premised on the narrow argument that the notion of problematic heritage is only limited to cases of racial differences or between the former colonizers and the colonized. Instead, by using examples of case studies in one of the countries in the region, the article demonstrates that all heritage is subject to review, either by new political dispensations or by future generations. Hence, when dealing with symbols accepted as heritage, interpretation as opposed to decontextualization or destruction must be resorted to as a guiding framework. When this happens, heritage then ceases to be a platform of contestation and becomes one of continuity.
Reference53 articles.
1. An Innocent Woman, Unjustly Accused? Charwe, Medium of the Nehanda Mhondoro Spirit, and the 1896–97 Central Shona Rising in Zimbabwe
2. Bulawayo Correspondent. (2019). Mthwakazi threat to take down Nehanda Statue from iconic Bulawayo Arts Centre. Retrieved, 28 October 2019, from https://www.newzimbabwe.com/mthwakazi-threat-to-take-down-nehanda-statue-from-iconic-byo-arts-centre/
3. Capa S. (2021). Colonial statues to be moved from legislature in Pietermaritzburg. The Witness. Retrieved, 27 October 2021, from https://www.news24.com/witness/news/kzn/colonial-statues-to-be-moved-from-kzn-legislature-in-pietermaritzburg-20211027