A New “Shield of the Weak”: Continued Paternalism of Domestic Violence Services in Uruguay

Abstract

Drawing on ethnographic and historical research, this article illuminates the limitations of the Uruguayan domestic violence services system. In spite of how advocates in Uruguay successfully used a human rights platform to secure legislation and services, this system now faces significant critique. Using Iris Marion Young’s work on the “logic of masculinist protection” and historical parallels in Uruguay’s welfare system, I discuss how a paternalistic approach may be to blame. I highlight how this paternalism contributes to the paternalism that problematically underlies gendered violence—reinforcing rather than addressing oppressive ideologies and structures that impede improving conditions for women.