Is eliciting dependency worth the effort? A study for the multivariate Poisson-Gamma probability model

Abstract

We examine whether it is worthwhile eliciting subjective judgements to account for dependency in a multivariate Poisson-Gamma probability model. The challenge of estimating reliability during product design motivated the choice of model class. For the multivariate Poisson-Gamma model we adopt an empirical Bayes methodology to present an estimator with improved accuracy. A simulation study investigates the estimation error of this estimator for different degrees of dependency and examines the impact of dependency being mis-specified when assessed by subjective judgement. Our theoretical and simulation findings give analysts insights about the value of eliciting dependency.