Juggling Logics on the Egyptian–Israeli Borderland: Soldiers between Securitization and Arbitrary Humanitarianism

Abstract

The following article investigates two interconnected border logics—securitization and humanitarianism—as they unfold as part of soldiers’ border experiences. We wish to show the alternating implementation of these two logics and to elaborate on how are they bound together. Our ethnographic fieldwork was conducted between 2012 and 2014 along a section of the Israeli–Egyptian border, consisting of observations, as well as off-site interviews with soldiers who were stationed along this border, and analysis of media reports and court affidavits. Dedicating special attention to the interactions between soldiers and irregular migrants, we argue that the ambiguities experienced by the soldiers at the ground level result in what we call “arbitrary humanitarianism.”