Cleft-Related Infanticide and Abandonment: A Systematic Review of the Academic and Lay Literature

Abstract

Objective: We aimed to describe the scope of cleft-related infanticide and identify issues that might inform prevention strategies. Design: Systematic reviews of both academic (eg, PubMed, EBSCOhost) and lay literature (eg, LexisNexis Academic, Google) databases were performed to identify all primary reports of cleft-related infanticide. All languages were included. Records before 1985 were excluded. Reference lists of all included reports were screened for potentially relevant records. Main Outcome Measures: Country of origin and excerpts that pertained to the concepts surrounding cleft-related infanticide were extracted. Extracted excerpts were examined using a content analysis framework. Results: Of the 1,151 records retrieved, 70 reports documented cleft-related infanticide from 27 countries. The largest number of reports was from China (14 reports; 48% of reports), followed by India (4; 14%) and Nigeria (4; 14%). However, 2 countries had 3 reports, 5 countries had 2 reports, and 17 countries had 1 report. Themes that emerged from excerpt analysis included stigma, lack of affordable cleft care, abandonment, orphanage overcrowding, and abuse and slavery. Conclusions: Cleft-related infanticide is a global problem. Initiatives to sensitize communities to cleft lip and/or cleft palate, provide timely and affordable cleft care, and build support systems for affected families may prove beneficial. Cleft care organizations have the opportunity to advocate for these initiatives, reduce the incidence of infanticide by providing or supporting timely and affordable cleft care, and demonstrate that children with successful cleft repairs reassimilate well into their communities.