Complicating factors in studio teaching dynamics: Dyad dissolution in post-secondary music studios

Abstract

Relationship dynamics between students and teachers are an essential element of one-on-one teaching and learning in music schools. The purpose of this study was to investigate factors leading to student–teacher dyad dissolution in post-secondary music performance studios. A total of 30 students and 30 teachers were interviewed. Interview questionnaires contained closed-ended rating scales and open-ended questions. Unstructured responses were transcribed, coded by units that each represented a contributing factor to dyad dissolution, and then subjected to a frequency count to determine decisive factors leading to dyad dissolution. All factors were subjected to the Framework of Social Levels, which is based on four levels – Interpersonal, Self, Other, and Outside. The majority of students’ dissolution factors were attributed at the Interpersonal level, whereas the majority of teachers attributed dissolution to factors at the Student ( Other) level. Participants cited several factors leading to dyad dissolution including different expectations, different professional goals, poor communication, incompatible personalities, student commitment, teacher teaching abilities, lesson satisfaction, and lack of personal connection.