Differences in the Exposure of the Lumbar Nerve Root Between Experts and Novices: Results From a Realistic Simulation Pilot Study With Force Sensors

Abstract

Study Design: Nonrandomized prospective trial. Objective: Several studies could demonstrate “learning curves” in almost every single surgical procedure for unexperienced surgeons. This is in sharp contrast to the rising quality requirements in public health care to provide surgical training at patients “expense.” The aim of this study was to visualize, measure, and set a baseline of the pressure load on the spinal nerve root during a simulated microdiscectomy on a standardized and validated model (RealSpine) under the influence of the level of surgical experience and individual skills. Methods: Five highly experienced spine surgeons and 5 trainees without considerable surgical experience were selected to perform a standardized microsurgical discectomy on a validated RealSpine simulator. Force-torque sensors were integrated in this simulator to measure the load on the nerve root. The forces were recorded every 125 ms. Results: We could identify cumulative for the total intervention as well as for defined single surgical steps of this procedure and as well in between the single subjects a significant higher tension and contusion forces on the nerve for the trainee group (Δp contusion 83-765 Nċs and Δp tension 159-1131 Nċs for the trainees. Δp contusion 16-171 Nċs and Δp tension 27-146 Nċs for the experts). Conclusion: We could measure a difference between unexperienced and experienced surgeons regarding the manipulations of the nerve root during a standardized simulated microdiscectomy. This possibility could be the starting point for a new and innovative surgical education to improve outcome without negative side effects of “learning curves.”