Use of Lithium, Carbamazepine, and Valproic Acid in a State-Operated Psychiatric Hospital

Abstract

Objective: To examine the prescribing of mood stabilizers (lithium, carbamazepine, and valproic acid) in a 500-bed state-operated psychiatric hospital in New York. Method: All 129 inpatients receiving mood stabilizers were identified and their medical records reviewed using a standardized drug use evaluation form. Diagnosis, other indications, and prior experience with mood stabilizers were examined, as well as outcome and adverse effects. Results: Approximately one-quarter of the inpatient population received a mood stabilizer. The frequency of carbamazepine use exceeded the use of lithium, with 72 patients receiving carbamazepine and only 62 receiving lithium. Twenty-eight patients received valproic acid. Indications found most frequently for carbamazepine use included assaultive or aggressive behavior (70% for those receiving carbamazepine as the only mood stabilizer). Of those patients with bipolar or schizoaffective disorder and receiving either lithium, carbamazepine, or valproic acid, 36% were prescribed carbamazepine (10% as a first-line agent) and 50% lithium (26% as a first-line agent). None of these indications for carbamazepine has been approved by the Food and Drug Administration. In general, positive outcomes were documented but without supporting objective measures. Significant adverse effects were documented in the medical record in one-quarter of the patients. Conclusions: There was widespread use of the three mood stabilizers examined, singly and in combination, for a variety of indications. Lithium and valproic acid remain more frequently prescribed for the treatment of bipolar and schizoaffective disorders. Monotherapy with carbamazepine or valproic acid results in statistically significantly fewer adverse effects than lithium or combination therapy (p values between p = 0.00038 and p = 0.006). Current clinical practice has endorsed the use of carbamazepine for aggressive or assaultive behavior, although there does not appear to be sufficient proof of effectiveness in the literature. Formal studies of carbamazepine's antiagressive effects should be conducted.