FDA Points-to-Consider Documents: The Need for Dietary Control for the Reduction of Experimental Variability within Animal Assays and the Use of Dietary Restriction to Achieve Dietary Control

Abstract

Standard protocols for conducting chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity studies have been refined over the years to carefully control for many variables. Nevertheless, over the last 2 decades, there has been a steady increase in variability, a decrease in survival, an increase in tumor incidence rates, and an increase in the average body weight of control animals among the various rodent species and strains used for toxicity testing. These observations have prompted an evaluation of chronic study designs to determine what factor(s) may be responsible for such confounding changes. Ad libitum feeding and the selection of successful breeders with rapid offspring growth is believed to be at least partially responsible for the heavier, obese rodents with which many laboratories are coping today. As a result of these changes, some studies used for the evaluation of safety have been deemed inconclusive or inadequate for regulatory purposes and either additional supportive studies have been requested and/or studies per se have been repeated. Research on the molecular mechanisms of caloric restriction and agent-induced toxicity at the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) National Center for Toxicological Research stimulated the first international conference on the biological effects of dietary restriction in 1989; this was followed in 1993 by an FDA workshop exploring the utility of dietary restriction in controlling reduced survival in chronic tests and an international conference in 1994 exploring the implications for the regulatory community of using dietary restriction in toxicity and carcinogenicity studies used in support of a sponsor's submission or in risk assessments. The outcome of that conference was the FDA's commitment to develop Points-to-Consider documents that address the issue of dietary control in chronic toxicity and carcinogenicity studies.