Comparison of two XML query languages from the perspective of learners

Abstract

Two XML query languages were tested for intuitivity, learnability and memorability. The languages differ with relation to the query structures like the use of variables, iterators and reference to attributes. One of the languages, XQuery, is a procedural, expressive and data-oriented query language that is suitable even for programming purposes; the other, XIL, is more declarative, document-oriented query language with a simpler syntax. A query-writing test with the learners of the languages was executed. The study indicates that, in the query writing, the more procedural query language yields a greater number of correct queries. Similarity between the tested languages, and to SQL, is discussed from the point of view of learnability.