The costs of avoidable injury from childhood cancer: Litigate or mediate?

Abstract

We write as experienced paediatric practitioners who have been involved in medico-legal proceedings where cases related to childhood cancer practice have featured frequently. We will use the service evaluation of Professor David A Walker’s last 35 cases, where all but seven concerned children with tumours of the brain or spine to illustrate the concerns that families raise. We refer to the evidence from the HeadSmart programme ( www.headsmart.org.uk ), which seeks to accelerate diagnosis by raising awareness of the disease and symptoms. We use the experience of Dr Jonathan AG Punt to illustrate the legal issues that apply and explain the way that significant quantum calculations are applied to cases of this type. The current move by NHS Resolution to explore the expanded role of mediation will be discussed and the need for research to explore the precise way that mediation could be developed to offer an alternative approach to conflict resolution.