Simultaneous Venous-Arterial Doppler Ultrasound During Early Fluid Resuscitation to Characterize a Novel Doppler Starling Curve: A Prospective Observational Pilot Study

Abstract

Background: The likelihood of a patient being preload responsive—a state where the cardiac output or stroke volume (SV) increases significantly in response to preload—depends on both cardiac filling and function. This relationship is described by the canonical Frank-Starling curve. Research Question: We hypothesize that a novel method for phenotyping hypoperfused patients (ie, the “Doppler Starling curve”) using synchronously measured jugular venous Doppler as a marker of central venous pressure (CVP) and corrected flow time of the carotid artery (ccFT) as a surrogate for SV will refine the pretest probability of preload responsiveness/unresponsiveness. Study Design and Methods: We retrospectively analyzed a prospectively collected convenience sample of hypoperfused adult emergency department (ED) patients. Doppler measurements were obtained before and during a preload challenge using a wireless, wearable Doppler ultrasound system. Based on internal jugular and carotid artery Doppler surrogates of CVP and SV, respectively, we placed hemodynamic assessments into quadrants (Qx) prior to preload augmentation: low CVP with normal SV (Q1), high CVP and normal SV (Q2), low CVP and low SV (Q3) and high CVP and low SV (Q4). The proportion of preload responsive and unresponsive assessments in each quadrant was calculated based on the maximal change in ccFT (ccFTΔ) during either a passive leg raise or rapid fluid challenge. Results: We analyzed 41 patients (68 hemodynamic assessments) between February and April 2021. The prevalence of each phenotype was: 15 (22%) in Q1, 8 (12%) in Q2, 39 (57%) in Q3, and 6 (9%) in Q4. Preload unresponsiveness rates were: Q1, 20%; Q2, 50%; Q3, 33%, and Q4, 67%. Interpretation: Even fluid naïve ED patients with sonographic estimates of low CVP have high rates of fluid unresponsiveness, making dynamic testing valuable to prevent ineffective IVF administration.