Vertical Partial Laryngectomy versus Supracricoid Partial Laryngectomy for Selected Carcinomas of the True Vocal Cord Classified as T2N0

Abstract

From an inception cohort of 204 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the true vocal cord classified as T2N0 and a minimum of 3 years of follow-up, the authors compare the oncological and functional outcomes following vertical partial laryngectomy (group 1; 85 patients) and supracricoid partial laryngectomy (group 2; 119 patients). The 10-year actuarial survival estimate was 46.2% for group 1 and 66.4% for group 2. Survival was statistically more likely to be reduced (p = .019) in group 1 than in group 2. The 10-year actuarial local control estimate was 69.3% for group 1 and 94.6% for group 2. Local recurrence was statistically more likely to occur (p < .0001) in group 1 than in group 2. Salvage treatment resulted in an overall 94.1% local control rate and a 78.1% laryngeal preservation rate for group 1 and an overall 99.2% local control rate and a 94.9% laryngeal preservation rate for group 2. The 10-year actuarial nodal control estimate was 81.7% for group 1 and 93.7% for group 2. Nodal recurrence was statistically more likely to occur (p = .028) in group 1 than in group 2. The 10-year actuarial estimate for patients without distant metastasis was 84.6% for group 1 and 95.1% for group 2. Distant metastasis was statistically more likely to occur (p = .05) in group 1 than in group 2. The hospital mortality rate was 1.2% for group 1 and 0.8% for group 2. The incidence of permanent gastrostomy was 0% for group 1 and 2.4% for group 2. The incidence of permanent tracheostomy was 1.2% for group 1 and 2.4% for group 2. The incidence of completion laryngectomy due to functional problems was 1.2% for group 1 and 0.8% for group 2.